The ECC debate is heating up at CECAM workshops. A growing cohort reports that charge‑scaling dramatically improves ion solvation and lipid binding without extra cost.
A vocal minority argues that a single scaling factor hides local polarization effects and forces re‑tuning of other force‑field terms. For them, “fixing” a model on the fly feels incompatible with force‑field development rigor.
Both sides cite solid papers and real‑world results, yet the conversation stalls at conferences. I’m not taking a side; I’m asking the community to list the remaining tests, share benchmark data, and decide where ECC belongs in the toolbox.
What would it take for a consensus—more validation studies, standardized protocols, or a joint workshop?